The sharp, sudden pain and sickening "crack" or "pop" when you fall on your shoulder is a feeling you can't miss. One of the most common broken bones in the body is a broken collarbone (clavicle fracture). The next step is usually a long, stressful, and expensive trip to the emergency room, where you will be sent to an orthopedic surgeon. But for most of these common fractures, there is a better way to heal. Direct Primary Care (DPC) is a simpler, more convenient, and much cheaper way to get better.
A clavicle fracture is a break in the collarbone, which is the long, thin bone that runs from your shoulder to your breastbone. This kind of injury happens a lot, especially to young people who are active and older people who fall.
The Most Common Type: About 80% of all broken clavicles happen in the middle third of the bone, which is called the midshaft.
The Good News: Most Broken Collar Bones Don't Need Surgery This is the most important thing to know. The vast majority of these common midshaft clavicle fractures are "minimally displaced," meaning the broken ends of the bone are still well-aligned. For decades, research and guidelines from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) have shown that these fractures heal very well with nonoperative treatment, which means keeping the arm still in a sling.
In Direct Primary Care (DPC), patients pay a membership fee and can see their doctor whenever they want. The DPC model's focus on access, affordability, and giving the right level of care is a game-changer for a common orthopedic injury like a broken clavicle. Here are some reasons why DPC is the best option for this injury:
A "one-stop shop" for diagnosis and treatment: DPC can make the whole process easier, so you can go from being hurt to having a treatment plan in one afternoon.
Quick Access and Evaluation: If you hurt yourself, you can call or text your DPC doctor and get an evaluation the same day.
Affordable Imaging: Your DPC doctor can send you to a nearby, independent imaging center for an X-ray. The price is usually already set and is much lower than the price of an ER X-ray.
Immediate, Definitive Care: After the X-ray shows that you have a simple, non-displaced fracture, your doctor can fit you with a sling, make a plan for managing your pain, and teach you everything you need to know about the healing process in one visit without rushing.
Expert Nonoperative Management (The Best Way to Care): DPC is in a great position to give the care that guidelines say is best for most clavicle fractures.
This method avoids the high costs, long wait times, and hassle of going to the emergency room and seeing an orthopedic specialist for a simple injury that doesn't need to be seen.
Studies show that treating simple fractures in primary care has the same results as treating them by orthopedic surgeons, but at a much lower cost.
Follow-up that is easy and ongoing: Your DPC doctor will be with you every step of the way as you heal.
Close Monitoring: They make it easy to schedule follow-up visits to check on your healing and take X-rays again if necessary.
Guided Rehabilitation: They can tell you when it's safe to start moving your shoulder again and set up a time for you to see a physical therapist to help you get your strength and range of motion back.
When to Refer: DPC doctors are very well trained to spot the exact "red flags" that need immediate surgical evaluation, like a lot of bone movement, the bone "tenting" the skin, or any nerve or blood vessel damage. They make sure you only see a surgeon when you really need to.
Case 1: David, 40, falls off his bike and hurts his shoulder. He calls his DPC doctor and goes to see him an hour later. The doctor thinks he might have a broken collarbone, so he sends him for an X-ray that costs only USD 60. The movie shows that there is a minimally displaced midshaft fracture. The doctor puts him in a sling, talks to him about how to control his pain, and sets up a follow-up visit. David doesn't have to pay a USD 2,500 emergency room bill and gets personalized care from his trusted doctor.
Case 2: Emily, 32, is getting better after her DPC doctor helped her heal a broken collarbone. She doesn't know what activities are safe after four weeks. She sends her doctor a short text. The doctor answers and says that she can start doing some gentle pendulum exercises for her shoulder, but she should keep avoiding lifting. This helpful advice makes Emily feel better about her recovery and gives her peace of mind.
A: I broke my collarbone. Isn't it necessary for me to see an orthopedic surgeon? A: No, for the most common type of clavicle fracture. There is clear evidence that non-operative treatment in a sling works very well for simple, minimally displaced midshaft fractures. Your DPC doctor is very good at diagnosing and treating this common injury.
Q: Isn't surgery a better or faster way to get better? A: Not for simple breaks. Surgery doesn't make most clavicle fractures heal faster or better. It also has a lot of risks, such as infection, nerve damage, and problems with the plate or screws, and it doesn't offer any clear advantages over sling immobilization.
Q: How can DPC help me save money if I break a bone? A: The savings are big. You can avoid paying a very high emergency room facility fee and a separate, high-cost orthopedic specialist consultation by getting all of your care in a primary care setting, from the first diagnosis and X-ray to all of your follow-up visits. In a DPC setting, the total cost of care for a broken clavicle is often only a small part of what it would be in a traditional insurance-based system.
DPC has clear benefits for this very common injury because
Giving care that is based on guidelines and is worth a lot: Expertly treating most clavicle fractures without surgery, which is the standard of care based on evidence.
Avoiding Huge Costs and System Problems: Keeping patients from going to the ER or a specialist for a simple injury that costs a lot of money and takes a long time.
Providing a healing experience that is easy and well-organized: Your DPC doctor is the only person you can talk to about your diagnosis and rehabilitation.
A broken collarbone is painful and annoying, but it doesn't have to be a long, expensive medical problem. Direct Primary Care is a simpler, cheaper, and very effective way to get better. You get care from the doctor who knows you best, and you can relax knowing that they are taking care of you.
Previous Post
