Primary care and cash-pay doctors in Carmel, IN

Updated November 2026How we check doctors

39 doctors in Carmel Closest first View on a map
Photo of Barbara K. Siwy, MD

Barbara K. Siwy, MD

Plastic Surgery physicianConcierge
Rated 5.0 out of 55.08 reviews
Siwy Plastic Surgery · Carmel, IN
Medical school Indiana University (1980)
Training Plastic surgery, Indiana University School of Medicine
  • Body reshaping
  • Skin tightening
  • Wrinkle removal
Photo of Christy Watson, MD

Christy Watson, MD

Functional Medicine physicianConcierge
BodyBarMD · Carmel, IN
Medical school Indiana University School of Medicine
  • Hormone replacement therapy
  • Medically guided weight loss

Katherine Nolan, MD

Dermatology physicianConcierge
Carabella Dermatology · Carmel, IN
Medical school Mount Sinai School of Medicine
  • Medical dermatology
  • Cosmetic dermatology
  • Surgical dermatology
Photo of Keyla Matthews, FNP

Keyla Matthews, FNP

Family Medicine nurse practitionerDPC
Cool Creek Family Health · Carmel, IN
Nursing school Indiana University, BSN (2017)
  • Relationship-based primary care
  • Preventive care
  • Lifestyle medicine
Photo of Candice Jackson Parrish, MSN

Candice Jackson Parrish, MSN

Psychiatry nurse practitionerConcierge
Empower You Mental Health & Wellness · Carmel, IN
Graduate school University of Indianapolis (MSN)
  • Executive wellness
  • Burnout recovery
  • Anxiety treatment
Photo of Olaniyi Osuntokun, MD

Olaniyi Osuntokun, MD

Psychiatry physicianConcierge
IN Focus First · Carmel, IN
Medical school University of Ibadan College of Medicine
Training Psychiatry, Indiana University School of Medicine and Indiana University Hospital and Clinics
  • Adult psychiatric evaluation
  • Adolescent ADHD
  • Bipolar spectrum disorders

Elizabeth R. Grethen, MD

Endocrinology physicianConcierge
Impact Endocrinology · Carmel, IN
Medical school Loyola University Stritch School of Medicine
Training Internal Medicine, Indiana University, Indianapolis
  • Diabetes
  • Thyroid disorders
  • Osteoporosis
Photo of Melanie Kingsley, MD

Melanie Kingsley, MD

Dermatology physicianConcierge
MK Dermatology · Carmel, IN
Medical school Indiana University School of Medicine
Training Dermatology, Indiana University School of Medicine
  • Medical dermatology
  • Cosmetic dermatology
  • Botulinum toxin injections
Photo of Simranjit Singh, MD

Simranjit Singh, MD

Functional Medicine physicianConcierge
The Functional MDs · Carmel, IN
Medical school Dayanand Medical College and Hospital
Training Internal medicine, University of Illinois (2013 to 2016)
Photo of Lindsay Moore, MD

Lindsay Moore, MD

Family Medicine physicianDPC
Westfield Premier Physicians · Carmel, IN
Training Indiana University School of Medicine
  • Breastfeeding Medicine
  • Lactation care
  • Lactation consults
Photo of Kathleen Hanover, MD

Kathleen Hanover, MD

Dermatology physicianConcierge
Rated 4.5 out of 54.58 reviews
Dermatology Inc. · Carmel, IN
Medical school Indiana University School of Medicine
Training Dermatology, Indiana University School of Medicine
  • Medical dermatology
  • Surgical dermatology
Photo of Farah Myers, FNP

Farah Myers, FNP

Family Medicine nurse practitionerDPC
Rated 5.0 out of 55.08 reviews
Cool Creek Family Health · Carmel, IN
  • Lifestyle medicine program
  • Nutrition advice
  • Physical activity advice

Nicholas Jenkins, MD

Internal Medicine physicianDPC
Rated 5.0 out of 55.08 reviews
Evergreen Internal Medicine · Carmel, IN
Medical school University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences
Training Indiana University Medical Center
  • Primary care for adults
Photo of Holly Smith, MD

Holly Smith, MD

Family Medicine physicianDPC
Rated 5.0 out of 55.08 reviews
Fiat Family Medicine · Carmel, IN
Medical school Indiana University School of Medicine
Training Family Medicine, St. Vincent Hospital (2016)
  • Fertility awareness
  • Natural family planning
  • Creighton Model NaProTECHNOLOGY

Compare cash-pay doctors in Carmel, IN

Same order as the list above. A comparison, not a ranking.

DoctorTypeEducation and trainingReviews
Barbara K. Siwy, MDConcierge · Plastic Surgery physicianPlastic surgery, Indiana University School of Medicine 5.0 (8)
Christy Watson, MDConcierge · Functional Medicine physicianIndiana University School of Medicine
Katherine Nolan, MDConcierge · Dermatology physicianMount Sinai School of Medicine
Keyla Matthews, FNPDPC · Family Medicine nurse practitionerIndiana University, BSN (2017)
Candice Jackson Parrish, MSNConcierge · Psychiatry nurse practitionerUniversity of Indianapolis (MSN)
Jessica Walsh, PMHNPConcierge · Psychiatry nurse practitioner
Olaniyi Osuntokun, MDConcierge · Psychiatry physicianPsychiatry, Indiana University School of Medicine and Indiana University Hospital and Clinics
Elizabeth R. Grethen, MDConcierge · Endocrinology physicianInternal Medicine, Indiana University, Indianapolis
Risa Davidson, DODPC · Pediatrics physician
Melanie Kingsley, MDConcierge · Dermatology physicianDermatology, Indiana University School of Medicine
Simranjit Singh, MDConcierge · Functional Medicine physicianInternal medicine, University of Illinois (2013 to 2016)
Lindsay Moore, MDDPC · Family Medicine physicianIndiana University School of Medicine
Kathleen Hanover, MDConcierge · Dermatology physicianDermatology, Indiana University School of Medicine 4.5 (8)
Kate O'Leary, MDConcierge · Reproductive Endocrinology and Infertility physician 5.0 (10)
Farah Myers, FNPDPC · Family Medicine nurse practitioner 5.0 (8)
Nicholas Jenkins, MDDPC · Internal Medicine physicianIndiana University Medical Center 5.0 (8)
Holly Smith, MDDPC · Family Medicine physicianFamily Medicine, St. Vincent Hospital (2016) 5.0 (8)
Jane Unaeze, MDConcierge · Dermatology
Kirsten M. Turchan, MDConcierge · Dermatology physician
Lauren D. Fahey, PA-CConcierge · Dermatology physician assistant

About cash-pay doctors in Carmel, IN

Carmel has 14 doctors who offer direct primary care, which is a monthly membership fee that patients pay their primary care practice. The middle of the adult monthly prices posted by the 8 practices in Carmel that list a price is $130 a month. The page lists 39 doctors at 26 practices, including Dermatology Inc. and Midwest Fertility Specialists. Family medicine, dermatology and psychiatry appear on the list, and 33 doctors have confirmed board certification.

Questions about cash-pay doctors in Carmel, IN

How many cash-pay doctors are in Carmel?

FindMyDirectDoctor lists 39 cash-pay doctors in Carmel, IN at 26 practices. 14 are direct primary care (DPC) doctors and 25 are listed under concierge or another cash-pay practice type. We last checked this list in November 2026.

Which specialties can I find?

The most common are family medicine (10), dermatology (6), reproductive endocrinology and infertility (5), functional medicine (4), and psychiatry (3).

Which doctors offer telehealth?

7 of the 39 doctors list telehealth visits. Each profile says which visits are offered.

Are these doctors board certified?

We confirmed board certification for 33 doctors on this list. Each profile shows the board and the specialty.

How many of these doctors publish their fees?

6 of the 39 doctors have a fee we confirmed on the practice's own website. The fee is on each of their profiles.

What do patients say about them?

15 of the 39 doctors have patient reviews on FindMyDirectDoctor, 123 reviews in total. Each tile shows the doctor's rating and review count.

Do these doctors take insurance?

It depends on the practice. Many direct primary care and concierge practices charge a membership fee instead of billing insurance for office visits, and some also accept insurance. Each profile says how its practice works when the practice states it.